How Medieval Philosophers Attempted to Prove the Existence of a God

Historical analysis and comparison of theories from St. Anselm and Ibn-Sina

Ahad Sheriff
6 min readJan 13, 2020
mik38 via Getty Images

It takes greater faith to believe that an unseen God exists than it does to dismiss it. This is problematic to philosophers and people of religion since you cannot physically confirm that god is there. As a result, early-medieval philosophers such as St. Anselm and Ibn-Sina (Avicenna) attempted to prove the existence of god using vastly different methods rationally.

St. Anselm was an 11th-12th century monk and the Archbishop of Canterbury who was famous for his ontological proof, a philosophical argument for the existence of God.

The ontological argument is a fascinating argument for the presence of an all-knowing, perfect deity. While there are several different versions of this argument, in the end, it exists to show that it is self-contradictory to deny that there exists the highest possible being — god. Anselm described his case in the Proslogion as follows (Note: “something god-like” refers to “that-than-which-nothing-greater-can-be-conceived”):

“Even the fool is forced to agree that [something god-like] exists in his mind, since he understands this when he…